Phones answered 24/7Baltimore, MD
Call (833) 751-2102
Guide

Counting the layers on a Baltimore rowhouse roof

How a roofer finds the coverings stacked on a Baltimore rowhouse roof without guessing: the edge, the attic, the cut and what the count changes.

Illustration for the guide "Counting the layers on a Baltimore rowhouse roof" (Baltimore, MD)
Short answer

A layer count is a measurement. On an attached house it is read at the edge and from the attic rather than guessed from the surface. No sourced figure gives a typical number for Baltimore rowhouses, so this page explains how the count is made and why it changes the next job.

Key takeaways

  • The surface of a roof shows only its top covering, so a layer count has to be read at the edge, at a penetration or from underneath.
  • A parapet or front cornice often shows the cross-section of the stack more clearly than any part of the field.
  • The attic is a second place to look, where the deck and any older work at the rafters show how the roof has been built up.
  • Each layer changes the tear-off, the disposal and the load the structure carries, so the count belongs in the written scope.
  • An older metal covering found beneath later work is a fact to record in writing before it is removed or covered again.
  • No layer number is printed here, because none is sourced for the city's rowhouse stock and a number would only be a guess.

Why does the top covering hide the count?

Newer covering is laid over older covering, and from the sidewalk or the roof surface only the newest layer can be seen. The count is a question of what lies underneath the top surface.

On a low roof the top covering is often the only part visible from a window or from street level, and it can look sound while the layers beneath it are worn, split or wet. A surface that appears to be one covering may be the top of a long run of repairs and recoverings.

This is why a count cannot be read reliably from a photograph of the roof taken from the street. A camera records the newest material, and the older stack sits under it. The count needs access to an edge, an opening or the underside of the deck to be made with confidence.

Owners sometimes assume that a roof which looks new has been laid once. That assumption is worth testing, because a recovered roof that was never stripped carries its earlier coverings into the next job, and the next roofer has to find them before the work can be priced.

What does the parapet or cornice show?

The edge of a flat roof behind a parapet or a front cornice is where the stack is most often exposed in cross-section, once the flashing has been lifted and relaid.

The city's preservation commission records that early nineteenth-century rows carried low, detailed cornices, and it asks for documented deterioration before a cornice is replaced. Where a cornice or parapet is part of the historic fabric, the edge is a record of the roof as well as a line of protection, and a roofer working there should note what is visible before anything is touched.

A lifted flashing, a cut at the cap or a worn edge can reveal several coverings in a few inches of depth. Each layer shows as a band of different material, often with a different color, and the bands can be counted and photographed without disturbing the rest of the roof.

Ask for the edge to be photographed in close detail, with a scale held beside it. A photograph of the stack is a better record than a verbal count, and it stays useful to the next person who has to plan work on the same roof.

What can the attic show?

The underside of the deck and the rafters show how the roof was built and whether it has been worked on from below, which often matches the count taken from above.

From the attic a roofer can see the boards or sheathing, their thickness and spacing, and any patching or fastening that suggests earlier work. Staining on the underside also shows where water has traveled, which is useful when the count and the leak point need to be read together.

The attic cannot show every layer, because the covering is above the deck and out of sight. What it does show is whether the deck has been overlaid, whether it is sound and whether the roof structure has been altered over time, and each of those facts changes what the replacement has to allow for.

Visiting the attic with the roofer is a sensible step. Two readings, one from above and one from below, are far harder to dispute than a single verbal count, and they give the owner a clearer record of what was found and where.

How is a count recorded properly?

A count is recorded as a list: each layer named by its general material, its approximate position in the stack, the location where it was seen and a photograph with a scale.

The record should say where the count was taken. A count made at the front parapet and a count made at the rear hatch may differ, because the roof was built or repaired in different sections at different times, and the scope should say which readings it relies on.

Each layer should be described by its general type rather than by a product name. Describing it as a mineral-surfaced cap, a tar-and-gravel layer or a sheet membrane is enough for a scope to be read, and it avoids turning a technical record into a sales document for any one manufacturer.

Keep the record with the house papers. A roof count written today is the starting point for every later repair, insurance inspection or sale, and an owner who has it can compare the next roofer's findings against the first without starting the count again from nothing.

Why does the count change the weight?

Each covering adds dead load to the roof structure, and several layers on a low roof can matter more than any single one. The count tells the next person whether the structure has been asked to carry more over time.

Dead load is the weight of the roof itself. Layers of covering, insulation, ballast and any retained water all add to it, and a low roof that has been recovered several times is carrying the cumulative weight of every earlier decision on top of its original structure.

This page does not give a load figure, because the structure of each house is different and a load calculation needs the framing, the spans and the condition of the members. What the count gives an engineer or a roofer is the starting input for that calculation, not the answer to it.

Where the count is high, the scope should say whether the structure has been assessed and what happens if it has not. Removing the layers before the new system goes on is the usual way to return the roof to a known load, and it should be priced as part of the work rather than treated as an optional extra.

What happens to an older metal covering?

An older metal covering found beneath later work is a historic and structural fact. It should be recorded and photographed before it is removed, covered or left in place.

Where a metal covering is found under later coverings, its condition, its seams and the way it was fixed are worth noting. Metal of that age can be a sound base or a corroded one, and the difference decides whether it can be left in place or has to be taken off.

Leaving an old metal covering in place under a new system is a decision with consequences. It adds weight, it can trap moisture and it hides the condition of the deck below. A roofer who proposes it should say why and record what the deck looked like before the new covering was laid.

If the house is in a district or is a landmark, the older metal may also be part of the character that a review is meant to protect. Ask before it is removed, and keep the photographs with the house papers in case the question comes up later.

How does the count affect the next replacement?

The count recorded now is the baseline the next roofer will use. A roof with a good record is quicker and fairer to replace than one whose stack is a matter of memory.

A replacement is priced from what is found, and what is found is largely the layer stack. An owner who can produce a dated count with photographs gives the next roofer a head start and reduces the number of allowances that have to be written as unknowns.

Records also protect the owner. If a later dispute arises about what was removed, what was left and what was found beneath, a written count with photographs settles the question faster than anyone's recollection, including the recollection of the roofer who did the work.

The count should be updated whenever the roof is touched. A repair that adds a patch, a recovered section or a new flashing changes the stack, and a record that is not kept current stops being a useful guide to the next job within a few years.

What should you ask a roofer about the count?

Ask how the count was taken, where, and how it will be written down. The answers show whether the roofer has actually looked at the stack or is working from a guess.

Ask which edges were opened, whether the attic was checked, and whether the count was made in more than one place. A single reading from one corner describes one corner, and a roof with a long history may have been worked on in sections.

Ask whether the count will appear in the written scope, with the photographs attached. A roofer who will not put the layers on paper before the work starts is asking you to accept the scope on trust, which is a poor basis for any contract.

Ask what happens if the stack is different from what was expected once the old covering is off. The answer should describe a stop, a photograph, a written change and an agreed price for the change, not a quiet adjustment that appears only on the final bill.

Frequently asked questions

Can I count the layers myself?

Do not go onto a wet, icy or storm-damaged roof to do it. Look at the edges from the ground or a window, photograph anything visible, and ask the roofer to do the count with access to the attic and the edge.

Does a layer count tell me the roof is failing?

No. It tells you what has been put on the roof over time. Whether the roof is failing depends on the condition of each layer and of the deck beneath.

Why does the attic matter if the layers are above the deck?

The attic shows the deck from below, how the roof was framed and whether it has been worked on. Those facts change what a replacement has to allow for, even though the coverings themselves are out of sight.

Do I have to remove every layer?

Not always, but the decision belongs in the written scope. A roofer who proposes leaving a layer in place should say why, record its condition and explain what that means for the weight and the deck.

What if I find an old metal roof under the newer covering?

Stop and photograph it before anything else is removed. Ask the roofer to record its condition in the scope, and check whether the house sits in a district where its removal would need review.

Sources

  1. Baltimore City Commission for Historical and Architectural Preservation, hearing minutes

This guide is general information for Baltimore City homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.

One call and it gets handled.

Tell us when you need someone and we book the earliest visit a help technician has, and you approve the price before any work starts.

Keep reading

More guides

WhatsApp