Deciding between repair and replacement
Replacement is the better choice when the failure is spread across the roof, not when it sits at one point.
A repair is sensible when the rest of the covering has life left and the fault is local. Replacement makes more sense when wear appears on every slope, when the deck is soft in several places, or when the flashing has been reworked so often that the joints have lost their original form.
The decision should rest on findings rather than on a number of years. The roofer explains what was seen on the deck, in the layers and at the flashing, and the homeowner can weigh that explanation against the house as it stands.
What the scope has to cover
A written scope lists each part of the roof, what is done to it and why, so nothing is left to be decided on the day.
The scope is the working document for the whole job. It should be specific about the deck and the boards to be replaced, and it should name the underlayment type and how it is lapped. A vague line such as renew flashing tells the homeowner little, while a line that names the wall, the chimney or the vent and the metal to be used tells them exactly what will happen.
It should also cover the attic. Ventilation at the ridge and eave, the balance between them and any penetrations that are being re-flashed belong in the scope, because they affect how the new roof performs in summer and winter.
- Deck condition and each board to be replaced
- Underlayment type and the lap at each course
- Flashing at every wall, chimney and vent
- Attic ventilation at the ridge and the eave
- Drainage at the eave, the valleys and any outlet
Warranties and the paperwork that follows
The paperwork is part of the job. A homeowner should leave with a record that says what was installed and what the installer promises.
Any warranty the installer offers should be handed over in writing, with a clear statement of what it covers and for how long. Read it before the crew leaves, and ask about any term that is unclear, because the terms decide what happens if a problem appears later.
The record should also include the product name and color, the location of each flashing detail and a sketch of the roof. A future roofer will need those facts to repair the work and to match a new covering if one is ever needed.
Timing the work around the weather
Replacement can be stopped by rain, so the roofer should say in advance what happens when the weather turns mid-job.
A roof is open for the length of the job, and an open deck is exposed to rain. A good roofer covers the exposed area each evening, dries the deck before laying material over it, and keeps the rest of the roof sealed so a shower does not reach the rooms below.
Homeowners should ask how the crew handles a forecast storm. The answer should cover covering the open area, pausing the work safely and the order in which sections are finished, so the house is never left without protection overnight.
Protecting the house during the work
The yard, the attic and the rooms below all need protecting before the first board comes up.
Plants, paths and parked vehicles are cleared from the drop zone, and a magnetic sweep and debris container are set in place. Attic openings are sealed against dust and nails, and the top-floor ceiling is covered where the work sits directly above it.
Gutters are cleared before the job starts and checked again when it ends, because the old covering sends a great deal of grit into the drains while it is being removed.